Now there’s a turn up for the BHA.
Hopefully enough to make the BHA think about its position.
Hopefully we’re beyond this being “just a bit of fun”.
[Video Here. No time to watch the whole right now, but after Copson vs the outgoing Archbishop, you can already see where the more subtle argument lies. Organized churches as agencies of communal humanity and tradition, BHA same as CofE in this respect. Immediate unmediated communities - social media etc - allow freedom of communication and thought, but they bring no "conservative" narrative to the whole (*). Social, cultural and intellectual evolution without conservatism cannot progress, any more than biological evolution, merely change and repeat errors. The "aim" - purpose and meaning - needs to be enshrined "metaphysically" (or maybe "transcendentally") beyond the current process and content - even the concept of humanity beyond individuals - "bigger than themselves". BHA is currently too naive and "scientistic" about where that value is maintained. Dawkinzzzzz .... when will he let go of childish things .... sarcastic, arrogant, ignorant, dogmatist and childish. How could this debate go any other way? As a humanist I'm embarrassed by the BHA.]
[Having listened on, Copson loses it at 1:07 by saying in his very own words that he is NOT actually for the motion as stated. Hope for him. Unmitigated disaster for the BHA. Tariq Ramadan and most of the students all very impressive. (*) As Douglas Murray says - we'd find ourselves living "The Only Way is Essex". The opposition wins hands down - anyone know the actual voting numbers?]